Walk-In Shower or Tub - Smart Choices for Bathroom Remodeling in NJ

When planning a bathroom remodeling project in New Jersey, homeowners often face a key decision: should you install a walk-in shower or keep a bathtub? Both options provide unique benefits in terms of functionality, style, and home value. Choosing the right option depends on your space, lifestyle, and design goals. 

This guide explores the pros, cons, and expert insights to help you make the smartest choice for your bathroom remodel. 

1. Understanding Today’s Bathroom Trends in New Jersey

New Jersey homeowners are increasingly leaning toward modern, space-efficient bathroom designs. Walk-in showers have grown in popularity for their sleek look and easy maintenance, while bathtubs continue to provide comfort, relaxation, and appeal in master bathrooms. 

Many homeowners now choose a combination of both options to enjoy convenience and luxury while boosting resale value. 

2. Walk-In Showers: A Modern Upgrade for Everyday Living 

Walk-in showers are practical, stylish, and ideal for both small and contemporary bathrooms. Their open design makes spaces feel larger and more inviting. 

Benefits of Walk-In Showers: 

• Accessibility: Low or no threshold designs are perfect for seniors and families. 

• Low Maintenance: Fewer corners and seams make cleaning easier. 

• Visual Space: Clear glass panels create the illusion of a bigger area. 

• Design Flexibility: Works well with tiles, natural stone, or acrylic panels.

Tips: Adding a rainfall showerhead, built-in storage niches, and recessed lighting can create a spa-like experience. 

Considerations: Walk-in showers do not offer a soaking experience and may require proper drainage to prevent water splashing. 

3. The Enduring Value of Bathtubs 

Bathtubs provide comfort and a sense of luxury. Many homeowners view a tub as a place to unwind and enjoy a spa-like experience at home. 

Benefits of Bathtubs: 

• Relaxation: Perfect for soaking after long days. 

• Family-Friendly: Ideal for bathing children and pets. 

• Resale Value: Many buyers prefer at least one bathtub in the home. 

• Variety of Styles: Options include freestanding tubs, soaking tubs, and whirlpools. 

Considerations: Bathtubs take up more space and use more water than showers. They may also be less accessible for older adults. 

4. Choosing Based on Your Lifestyle 

Consider how your bathroom will be used on a daily basis: 

• Busy adults often prefer a walk-in shower for speed and efficiency. 

• Families with children find tubs more practical. 

• Seniors may benefit from curbless showers for safety. 

• Homeowners who enjoy luxury may prefer a soaking tub. 

  
  

Your choice should reflect your lifestyle, not just trends. 

5. Space and Layout Considerations 

Bathroom size plays a critical role in determining your options: 

• Small Bathrooms: Walk-in showers maximize usable space and open up the room. 

• Medium Bathrooms: A shower-tub combo provides versatility. 

• Large Bathrooms: Installing both a freestanding tub and walk-in shower creates a luxury master suite. 

Consult licensed bathroom remodeling contractors in NJ to ensure plumbing, ventilation, and layout meet both design and code requirements. 

6. Budget and Cost Considerations 

Costs vary depending on materials and design choices: 

• Walk-In Showers: Typically $6,000–$12,000 depending on customization. 

• Bathtubs: Usually $4,000–$10,000, with luxury models higher. 

  
  

Walk-in showers may have higher upfront costs but are easier to maintain. Bathtubs can increase resale value, especially for family homes. 

7. Design Tips for NJ Bathrooms 

Thoughtful design makes any remodel stand out: 

• Use large-format tiles for a clean, spacious look. 

• Add LED lighting or skylights to brighten the space. 

• Incorporate neutral or earthy tones for a timeless aesthetic. 

• Include water-saving fixtures to reduce utility bills. 

• Choose slip-resistant flooring for safety. 

Professional designers can help combine style and functionality to maximize your bathroom’s potential. 

8. Combination Designs for Maximum Flexibility 

If your bathroom allows, combining a walk-in shower and bathtub provides the best of both worlds. A shower is perfect for busy mornings, while a tub offers a relaxing experience for evenings or weekends. This dual setup adds both comfort and resale value. 

Final Thoughts 

Walk-in showers offer a modern look and low maintenance, while bathtubs provide comfort and a spa-like experience. Your choice should align with your lifestyle, space, and long-term goals. Either option, when executed well, will enhance both comfort and home value.

Transform Your Bathroom with KBB Remodeling 

Whether you want a sleek walk-in shower, a luxurious tub, or both, KBB Remodeling brings your bathroom vision to life. Our team specializes in bathroom remodeling in NJ, delivering functional layouts, premium finishes, and expert craftsmanship.

Partner with trusted home renovation contractors NJ and turn your bathroom into a space you love. Contact KBB Remodeling today to start your project.